Skip to main content

Smart Solutions or Cellphone Bans For Schools - Can We Find a Balance?

The recent news on a possible ban on cellphones in New York City public schools has sparked quite the debate among school leaders, parents, and students. As an advocate for internet wellness, I believe it's essential to find a balance that embraces technology's potential while addressing concerns. Instead of imposing a blanket ban, why not explore ways to integrate smartphones and tablets constructively and safely into the classroom environment? These devices, when used appropriately, can be powerful educational tools, enhancing learning experiences and preparing students for a tech-driven world. 

As a former teacher, I do believe that cellphones in schools should be reserved for middle-school aged students and up. I feel at this age students may start having more independence and smart devices can keep them safe and the lines of communication open. 


But, within schools, I believe we are not utilizing smartphones and devices enough in the classroom or in the right ways. With proper training and intention, educators can harness these devices to support the curriculum in meaningful and effective ways. For instance, smartphones can be used for interactive learning activities, such as real-time quizzes and polls, content creation, and design or as tools for research during class projects. Educational apps can reinforce concepts taught in class, and features like augmented reality can bring subjects to life, providing students with immersive learning experiences. Furthermore, smartphones can facilitate collaboration through shared documents and communication platforms, allowing students to work together seamlessly.

In 2024, technology should be taking learning to the next level. Unfortunately, our educational systems have not fully adapted to or embraced our ever-changing tech and AI-driven world. Instead of viewing smartphones and devices as a threat, we should explore how they can enhance education and learning for all of us. Teaching students to use these devices responsibly and for more than social media and entertainment can foster critical thinking and massive creativity from an earlier age. By integrating technology into the classroom, we can prepare students to navigate and succeed in a rapidly evolving digital landscape. It's time to shift our perspective and leverage the tools at our disposal to cultivate a generation of innovative thinkers and problem solvers.



As Mayor Eric Adams and Schools Chancellor David Banks argue, "cellphones in schools are a distraction, lead to cyberbullying, and are often used inappropriately." By restricting access to inappropriate content and social platforms during school hours, we can ensure students remain focused. Schools can implement robust security measures. Network-level security controls can block out the nonsense and turn phones into valuable learning aids rather than sources of distraction. If issues arise, educators can confiscate devices.


However, we must acknowledge that socioeconomic status is a significant factor in the equitable use of smartphones in schools. Not all students have access to the latest technology, which can create disparities in learning opportunities. Schools can address this by providing devices for students who need them and ensuring all students have access to the internet during school hours. Additionally, implementing a Bring Your Own Device (BYOD) policy, coupled with financial support for students who cannot afford smartphones, can help level the playing field.

In an age where school emergencies are an unfortunate reality, I also recognize that having immediate access to communication tools is critical. Allowing students to keep their phones, with usage restricted to educational and emergency situations, strikes a balance between safety and discipline. The ability to quickly contact authorities or family members in case of an emergency is a crucial consideration that a total ban ignores.

Incorporating technology into schools and education shouldn't be seen as a threat or a challenge but as an opportunity. With thoughtful policies and the right safeguards, we can harness the benefits of smartphones and devices while minimizing their downsides. Balance is key, let's move forward with a mindset that embraces innovation inside the classroom and out and prepares our kids with life skills for shaping the future, rather than reverting to restrictive measures that deny the reality of our tech-driven world.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why 'Forever' on Netflix Is the Series We Didn’t Know We Were Waiting For

I don’t usually write reviews, but after watching Forever on Netflix, I had to make an exception. As a mom raising two Black kids in the digital age, this series felt like someone finally wrote a love letter to our reality — not the exaggerated, polished or filtered version, but the real one. And I don’t say this lightly: Forever is the most relatable, timely, and necessary show I’ve seen in a long time, especially when it comes to portraying young Black love. Forever was created and executive produced, by the brilliant Mara Brock Akil, yes, the same powerhouse behind Girlfriends and Being Mary Jane. With Forever, she reimagines Judy Blume’s classic novel through a fresh, modern very Black lens, setting it in 2018 Los Angeles and centering Black teen love, parenting, and digital trauma. Forever stars Lovie Simone as Keisha Clark and Michael Cooper Jr. as Justin Edwards, two  teens exploring first love while navigating social pressures, family expectations, and digital landmines....

Monitoring Matters: Apps to Keep Our Kids Safe Online

As a millennial mom who grew up alongside the internet (back when we had to fight for dial-up time and hope no one picked up the phone), I know firsthand that the digital world is equal parts amazing and chaotic. Recently, I glanced at a chat between my daughter and her friends—what they saw as harmless jokes could have easily been misinterpreted. Cue my mini heart attack. It was a wake-up call for both of us: them realizing that words can take on a whole new meaning online, and me realizing that parenting in the digital age is basically a full-time job... with no PTO. The Reality of the Digital Footprint The internet never forgets. Kids need to understand from the moment they go online that their devices are not private journals or diaries. Anything they post, send, or even joke about can be taken out of context, screenshotted, and follow them forever. The digital footprint they create today could impact their future opportunities, relationships, and even their mental well-being. Beyo...

Life Happens - Back to School Season - Screen Time Reset and Almost 40?

Hey friends! It's been a minute since I've had the chance to sit down and blog. Why? Because LIFE this summer has been a whirlwind. Camps, parties, work trips and trying to keep up a social life of my own...it was a lot. And let's be honest, there's still so much I didn't get around to. To top it off, my best friend is getting married in Cartagena, Colombia, and mentally, I'm already there!!! Trying to balance travel plans, family activities, and work...whew! And then came August—what August? I blinked, and we were already back to school. On the bright side, both of my kids are at the same school this year! Kristopher started kindergarten, and Khloe is in 5th grade. New school year, new level of parenting unlocked! With back to school comes a tech reset in the Bagley household. Let me be honest: our summer was all about flex time when it came to screen time. During the day, the kids are mostly offline, working on review activities or playing indoors or outside. ...